Q: What is the 8th song intended for the 3CD set of "17"?
Full Q: On the back of the 17 single Stephen says he recorded 23 new
songs 12 were included on I Love My Friends, and 8 were to accompany the 3CD set of 17... However there are only 7 extra songs on that set... Does anyone know what the 8th one was going to be?
A: There were nine extra songs on 17 (3CD set), yes a version of Hanging
Around had been released but this one is different and was re-recorded
without Alex James specifically to be released by Stephen as a solo artist.
So that added to the 12 (real songs) on ILMF makes 21. The only song that we can confirm was scheduled for I Love My Friends but didn't make it was "Hard For Her" which finally appeared on the b-side of "A Dream That We All Share" there may have been another one but Stephen has never mentioned what that track was. Stephen has a habit of sidelining extremely good songs either temporarily or permanently. Some make comebacks years later in a reworked form ("The Silence" was written for Paradise Circus 14 years previous to it's inclusion on Keep Going, for example). A couple of songs that we know about which were recorded around that time were Suburban Symphony and An Open Book. Chris was sent a different version of An Open Book in about 2001 and Suburban Symphony in 2002. They had been unearthed on SONY promo CDs which have not since come to light and only a few dozen were ever made up. When Stephen realised they had been found he decided to put them to official use, Suburban Symphony on a charity compilation and An Open Book accidentally appeared on Keep Going.
Posted on 18 Nov 2006 by Sabine